Homestar Runner
Flash-era cartoon comedy series, still online and still funny.
Homestar Runner is a Flash animation series that ran through the 2000s — Strong Bad Emails, in particular, is one of the most quoted pieces of early-internet comedy there is. The Brothers Chaps kept the site alive well past Flash's death by rebuilding the cartoons for modern browsers. Free, no signup, exactly as weird as you remember.
In the directory